Three Arizona Schools Candidates Hold Differing Views

andidates are running for the post of Superintendent ofrequirement of 59 percent. A “C” average
Public Instruction for the Arizona schools in thestudent within the Arizona schools only need answer
September 12th election. Current Superintendent Tomsix mathematics questions correctly out of 56. He also
Horne is running as the unopposed Republicanwould like to see AIMS administered as the state of
candidate, seeking his second term in office. TwoWyoming does its testing — students take the test
Democrats are challenging Horne — Slade Mead anddirectly on a computer, the results are instantly scored,
Jason Williams. Mead is a sports agent, a former stateand then the scores are immediately sent to the
senator, a former Kyrene School District boardteachers for evaluation.
member, and a former Republican. Williams is a formerSchool Vouchers. Another hot button for many
middle school math and science teacher, and a formereducators, parents and the community are school
executive director of a nonprofit organization thatvouchers, whereby some students may attend private
recruits teachers for low-income and rural areas.schools funded by the taxpayers. Under a newly
Two major issues that will be facing the newly electedpassed budget, that state has authorized $5 million in
superintendent are the Arizona Instrument to Measureprivate school vouchers for disabled and foster-care
Standards (AIMS) tests and school vouchers.students. All three candidates are opposed to
AIMS. This year was the first to require all high schoolvouchers for private schools.
seniors in the Arizona schools to pass the AIMS test inIncumbent Horne stated that Arizona schools already
order to graduate. The candidates have differingare the leading proponent for parental choice in the
views on AIMS and its use.nation, with charter schools, open enrollment policies,
Horne is a strong advocate of the graduationand tax credits. He noted that the Manhattan Institute
requirement, believing that it makes studentsranks the Arizona schools as number one out of 50 in
accountable for what they learn. He commented that itparental choice. He also pointed out that the state
makes Arizona schools students take their educationconstitution prohibits the use of public funds for religious
seriously, because they will not be handed a diploma ifor private schools.
they fake their way through school.Because the state legislature already passed the use
Williams would like the graduation requirementof school vouchers into law, Mead only stated his
eliminated and to use AIMS as a benchmark foropposition to them and that, if elected, he would ensure
learning, gauging just how well Arizona schoolsthat the Arizona schools accounted for every cent
students are retaining knowledge. He believes thisused for school vouchers.
would take the pressure off students, when used as aWilliams pointed out that private schools do not
diagnostic tool. Williams disagrees with Horneautomatically do a better job than public ones. He sees
concerning students taking learning more seriouslythe voucher system as a way of giving up on public
because of AIMS. He noted that 15,000 students, whoeducation in the Arizona schools.
enrolled as Arizona schools freshmen in 2002, hadThough these are the two hot-button issues in this
dropped out of school before the Class of 2006upcoming election, undoubtedly there are many more
graduated.for which the parents and communities of the Arizona
Mead agrees with Williams that AIMS would make aschools should be concerned. Ensure that you check
better assessment tool for the Arizona schools andout the three candidates and what they have to say
that the passing requirement for graduation beabout all of the issues — and make your voice heard
eliminated. He has stated that the current administrationin September by voting for the candidate of your
of AIMS is a “sham” with only a passing gradechoice.