Syntopical Reading - Don't Just Take My Word For It

Syntopical reading is a great tool to use to increasereader identifies in the works should be compared
reading knowledge and comprehension for the seriousacross the spectrum of authors.
high school or adult student. Another term for it wouldNext, readers using this in-depth approach to learning
be comparative reading, but the process involvesshould do the same thing with the following question -
reading and comparing multiple texts on the same"How are these different?" By adding into the charted
topic. When doing this, there are some fundamentalnotation system a new column that looks at
questions that readers can ask in order to set updifferences, serious students will be able to stretch out
syntopical comparisons. Doing this will allow readers todeeper meanings and implications in the various works.
take cross sections from each source, summarizeThat will lead to the fourth column - "How are these
them, analyze them, compare them to the others, anddistinctive?" That final question will lead the reader into
form independent perspectives on the truth or validitya dissection of the content at its most unique level.
of the reading material, thereby digging much deeperOnly after reviewing the finer points, however, will the
into the learning process.distinctiveness of any one work begin to stand out.
Syntopical reading allows authors to evaluate a varietyThe final step in syntopical reading is to review,
of sources based on asking key questions. Onecompare, "dissect," and critique the various points that
example of such a question might be, "How are theseeach author makes for the purpose of giving his or her
similar?" It is helpful to actually set up a chart or table inagreement or disagreement to the opinions. This is the
a computer document and to outline major tenets ofpoint where the deepest level of learning will occur as
each source and then note the various authors'students will begin to make informed decisions as to
perspectives on each major principle or concept. Oncethe spectrum of opinions that have been reviewed.
the similarities are outlined, then the serious studentThere may be additional sources that the reader will
should go on to address the question, "How are theseneed to consult at this point. Perhaps one of the
the same?" Notice the variance in the two questions.authors introduced a concept that none of the others
Similarities will point out places where the authors takedid. A serious student may want to include new
a different approach but arrive at nearly the same endauthors at this point. Ultimately, however, the student
result. "Sameness," however, indicates perfectreader will have an in-depth study in the topic at hand
agreement of the two points of view. If the seriousand will be far more prepared to form their own
reader is examining three or more sources, then thisconclusions and opinions on that study than if they had
analytical step may take some time, but it is well worthonly read and considered one source.
the effort. Each point or foundational "truth" that the